Vintage Christmas decor is all about pieces that look like they've been collected over the years: old-world greenery, warm wood, a little aged brass and lots of candlelight. I'd skip anything shiny and brand new looking, and start with one great wreath, a few wood candlesticks and one surface with real character. Here's what I've linked, with prices.
Vintage Christmas decor starts with old-world greenery
I love creating that cozy, collected Christmas look with classic holiday greenery, Norfolk pine garlands, vintage-inspired ornaments, neutral decor and lots of layered textures. On our mantel, I started with a mixed juniper garland from Darby Creek Trading, then layered in copper cedar and bronze pinecone sprays, bronze glitter seed branches and golden bronze berry picks. The bronze tones next to the winter landscape art are what make it feel old-world instead of brand new. My full layering method is in how I decorate a Christmas mantel with garland.
For a door, a mirror or above a console, a fruit wreath reads more vintage than a plain fir one. This one from Target has glossy green leaves, sugared fruit and pinecones with a brown bow.
Sugared Fruit Christmas Wreath

Target
Sugared Fruit Christmas Wreath $35.00 $35.00 USD
Pine, sugared fruit and pinecones with a bow at the bottom.
Old-world art and candlelight
The winter landscape over our fireplace does so much of the work on that mantel. A moody landscape in a dark wood frame instantly reads old-world, and it works long after the tree comes down. On the Moor is a lone tree on the plains in soft earth tones. It's made to order, so order early if you want it up for Christmas.
On the Moor Framed Art

Joon Loloi
On the Moor Framed Art $199.00 $199.00 USD
A moody landscape in earth tones, made to order.
Then add candlesticks. Instead of a matching set, I'd mix heights and finishes. The Greer candlesticks from Joon Loloi are turned wood with a bobbin shape in a rich mocha oak, in a shorter and a taller height, so you can stagger a few. Tuck them next to brass you already have and it looks like you found them over time. More ways to add glow are in my Christmas lighting ideas.
Greer Candlesticks, Mocha Oak

Joon Loloi
Greer Candlesticks, Mocha Oak $39.00 $39.00 USD
Turned wood in a warm mocha finish, priced each.
One surface with real character
A vintage room needs at least one piece with patina or handmade texture to hold the holiday styling. This is where I'd invest if you can, because a good table works all year long. The Aviva accent table has a base inlaid with handmade glazed tiles in a warm, earthy rust, so the color changes a little from tile to tile. It's perfect beside a chair with a candle and a few stems.
Aviva Accent Table, Rust Glazed Tile

Joon Loloi
Aviva Accent Table, Rust Glazed Tile $799.00 $799.00 USD
Handmade glazed tiles on an oak pedestal, so no two look alike.
For an entry or behind the sofa, the Quince reclaimed oak console has that worn, natural grain that makes greenery and candlesticks look right at home. In Cafe Brown it's a deeper, warmer wood.
Reclaimed Oak Waterfall Console, Cafe Brown

Quince
Reclaimed Oak Waterfall Console, Cafe Brown $1,400.00 $1,400.00 USD
Solid reclaimed oak with natural grain for an entry or behind the sofa.
Aged brass light
Bright, polished gold can make a room feel new. Brass with a softer finish and a pleated shade feels like it's been there for years. The Rennie sconce has scalloped pleated linen shades on a brass-finished stem, and I'd use it by a bed, over a console or in a dining nook.
Rennie Sconce, Brass

Joon Loloi
Rennie Sconce, Brass $299.00 $299.00 USD
Pleated linen shades on a brass-finished gooseneck stem.
Over an island or a dining table, these dome pendants from Nathan James come in a vintaged brass finish, so the garland and candles stay the star.
Metal Dome Pendant Lights, Vintaged Brass

Nathan James
Metal Dome Pendant Lights, Vintaged Brass $359.98
Dome shades in a vintaged brass finish; the price is for the pair.
A place to sit by the tree
A vintage Christmas room feels lived in when the seating has a little age to it. I'd go with leather or warm brown instead of anything white or nubby. The Quince barrel back chair in Chestnut has that cognac color that works with every warm wood above, at the dining table or pulled into a corner by the tree. Add one plaid pillow in red for the season and you're done. Want a small tree to set beside it? Here are my favorite small Christmas trees.
Italian Leather Barrel Back Dining Chair, Chestnut

Quince
Italian Leather Barrel Back Dining Chair, Chestnut $500.00 $500.00 USD
Chestnut leather that reads cognac next to warm wood.
Brian Plaid Pillow, Red

Joon Loloi
Brian Plaid Pillow, Red $34.00 $34.00 USD
Cotton windowpane plaid in red; the price is for the cover only.
If you love this look, my Ralph Lauren-inspired Christmas and old money Christmas decor posts have more brass, velvet ribbon and greenery that fit right in.
Shop the vintage Christmas look
The pieces from this post. Prices were checked on each retailer's site and can change, so check the current price before you buy.
Sugared Fruit Christmas WreathTargetShop
Greer Candlesticks, Mocha OakJoon LoloiShop
Aviva Accent Table, Rust Glazed TileJoon LoloiShop
Reclaimed Oak Waterfall Console, Cafe BrownQuinceShop
Metal Dome Pendant Lights, Vintaged BrassNathan JamesShop
On the Moor Framed ArtJoon LoloiShop
Rennie Sconce, BrassJoon LoloiShop
Brian Plaid Pillow, RedJoon LoloiShop
Italian Leather Barrel Back Dining Chair, ChestnutQuinceShop
Want to see whole rooms? Shop them on Shop the Look, or browse more of my finds in the Market.
