For neutral Christmas wrapping, I keep it to brown, gold and one vintage-style print, then tie everything with satin ribbon in brown and champagne. It looks cohesive under the tree, even when the wrapping happens at the last minute. Here's how I wrap and what I use.
1. Pick two solid papers and one print
I keep the paper to two solids and one pattern. My solids are a matte gold and a chocolate brown, both from Amazon, and the matte finishes mix so well together. The third paper is a vintage-style print with woodland animals and botanicals from Etsy. It adds just the right amount of texture and interest, and any vintage botanical or woodland print in brown and cream will do the same job.
WRAPAHOLIC Matte Gold Wrapping Paper

Amazon
WRAPAHOLIC Matte Gold Wrapping Paper $19.99
A 30-inch jumbo roll, 16.5 feet long, in a soft matte gold.
RUSPEPA Chocolate Brown Matte Wrapping Paper

Amazon
RUSPEPA Chocolate Brown Matte Wrapping Paper $8.99
Pearly chocolate brown, 17 inches by 32.8 feet.
2. Save the print for one or two boxes
Here's how I'd use the three papers. Put the print on one or two boxes only and let the solids carry the rest, so the pile never looks busy. I'd wrap the biggest boxes in brown to ground the stack and save the gold for smaller boxes, where it catches the tree lights. Keep the wrapping simple: crisp folds and tape on the inside matter more than fancy techniques.

3. Tie everything with satin ribbon
Satin ribbon is what makes plain paper look finished. I use brown and champagne gold satin ribbon from Amazon, and the pair works on every paper in the stack. I'd put brown ribbon on the gold and printed boxes and champagne on the brown ones, so each gift has a little contrast. A wide ribbon makes a fuller bow, so I'd go with 1 1/2 inches for the champagne and a 1-inch brown for the smaller boxes.
Fullive Champagne Gold Satin Ribbon

Amazon
Fullive Champagne Gold Satin Ribbon $6.99
1 1/2-inch satin, 30 yards, wide enough for a full bow.

4. Label them with kraft tags
I'd skip printed holiday tags here. Plain kraft to-and-from stickers match the brown paper and don't add another color, and they stick right on the box, so there's no hole punch or string to deal with.
Kraft To and From Gift Tag Stickers

5. Stack them under the tree
This is the part that does the decorating. In my photo at the top, the gifts sit in loose stacks beside the tree, big boxes on the bottom and small ones on top, with the papers mixed so the same color never sits side by side. Keeping everything neutral makes even simple gifts feel intentional. The tree behind them is our Balsam Hill tree, and the same brown and gold palette runs through my neutral Christmas tree and tree ribbon posts.
BH Balsam Fir Christmas Tree

Balsam Hill
The tree behind our gifts, gifted by Balsam Hill. It comes in several heights.
Still shopping for what goes inside the boxes? My Christmas decor gift guide and candle gift guide have ideas, and a hostess gift wrapped this way is an easy win.
Shop my wrapping supplies
The paper, ribbon, tags and tree from this post. Prices were checked on each retailer's site and can change, so check the current price before you buy.
Frequently asked questions
What wrapping colors go best with a neutral Christmas tree?
Brown, gold, cream and kraft all sit well with green branches and warm lights. Keep to two or three of them and repeat the same ribbon, and the gifts look like part of the tree.
Want to shop whole rooms? See them on Shop the Look, or browse more of my finds in the Market.
WRAPAHOLIC Matte Gold Wrapping PaperAmazonShop
RUSPEPA Chocolate Brown Matte Wrapping PaperAmazonShop
Fullive Champagne Gold Satin RibbonAmazonShop
Kraft To and From Gift Tag StickersAmazonShop
BH Balsam Fir Christmas TreeBalsam HillShop
